Tuesday, October 31, 2006
The art of engineering
The advert ends with the line, "The walls between art and engineering exist only in our minds."
There are a couple of ways to interpret the catch line and it really depends on how you view art and engineering (surprise, surprise). I would say the way that the advertising company wants you to interpret that statement is that BMW have highly engineered cars with wonderful aesthetics. My interpretation? Well, maybe less obvious and possibly more true to the artist's feelings.
Let us start by looking at the word "art". Here are two definitions from Dictionary.com,
1. the quality, production, expression, or realm, according to aesthetic principles, of what is beautiful, appealing, or of more than ordinary significance.
2. skill in conducting any human activity: a master at the art of conversation.
So we have two (of many) definitions, one focussing on aesthetics (the "typical" association with art) and another focussing on skill at doing something. I am going to diverge a little to tell you a story about my wife and the dentist - yes maybe you think that is strange, but bear with me for a bit...
My wife really dislikes the dentist (is that applause I hear in the back row?) - until she met a lady dentist in Pretoria. Now the first thing that my wife normally tells a dentist when she sits down in the chair is how much she does not like them and how she does not understand why anyone would like to become a dentist. Luckily this tends to break the ice and lead to a good relationship :). So when the topic of, "Why would anyone want to become a dentist?" came up with this particular dentist she responded by saying that for her it was a form of art. She really took pride in how she did her work so that it would be both aesthetically pleasing and functional. Obviously it requires a skillful dentist to do this well.
So who of you would have said that a dentist was an artist? (that is, other than a torture artist ;) )
Maybe the question that needs to be asked is how far apart art and engineering actually are. In general it seems that people put them at opposite sides of the spectrum with art being all about creativity and engineering all logical and scientific. I think that what Joe Average does not realise is the degree of creativity that engineering requires and that is most likely due to engineers lack of ability to explain what we do (see my previous post on this).
For me the art of engineering is so much more than just creativity - it is something that goes to the core of function, aesthetics, and problem solving. I believe that we as engineers need to create solutions that actually enhance people's lives. The point where all of this comes together is the point were we as engineers can start to be artists.
It is more than function and more than beauty - true engineering art should take your breath away and change the way you see the world. That is the kind of art that I want to create.
I've just realised that I can't think of something off the top of my head that embodies those principals. I'm going to have to go scratch around and find some examples of what I think encompasses the art of engineering (I see a "Top Ten" post coming on). Do you have anything that you think stands out as an amazingly engineered product? Let me know by posting a comment!
A final thought - take the time to be an artist at what you do. This will enhance the lives of the people around you, and most importantly your own life, and the ripple effect of that is huge.
PS. If you're looking for a great dentist in Pretoria (or Tshwane, or whatever you want to call it), try Dr. Cornel Cronje (drop me a line if you want her contact details).
__________________
PPS. I've added a "Current Reading" section to the links on the right so that you can check out what I'm (hopefully) enjoying at the moment. The link will take you through to the Exclusive Books website (I'm an affiliate) where you can buy books and have them delivered for free to your nearest Exclusive Books.
6 comments :
If you are leaving a comment with your Name and URL then make sure you put http:// in front of your URL for a correct link. You can use some HTML tags such as <a>, <b> and <i> in your comment. Thanks for your message - I appreciate it :)
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.
Search This Blog
Subscribe
Tags
About this blog
I'm Duncan Drennan and this blog is about spreading ideas regarding engineering, our environment and creating a better world. You can also follow me on Google Reader.
About Engineer Simplicity
Engineer Simplicity specialises in the design and development of electronic products.
Copyright Notice
Popular Posts
-
We are in the middle of an energy crisis and each of us need to make some dramatic changes to ensure that we have electricity, and that the ...
-
The short version (my "elevator pitch"): Compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) use about a fifth of the energy of a normal (incandescen...
-
As engineers we spend a lot of time solving problems. A customer has a problem and it needs to be fixed. The electronic boards you have just...
-
This post forms a part of the SA Blook . So what is our reality? South Africa has an unemployment rate of about 23%, a skills shortage crisi...
-
There are a lot of steps to turn an idea into a product. Each step requires care and attention to ensure that the best product is created. B...
-
So here we are, the first blog post...well, really, here I am. My name is Duncan Drennan and this is my blog on business, design, electronic...
-
eWaste is a particularly difficult issue to deal with as it contains many different materials and lots of extremely hazardous substances. I...
-
Electronic design automation tools like OrCAD , PADS and Altium Designer are part of an electronic engineer's day–to–day life. We need...
-
With 48 post over nearly three years, I am certainly not a prolific blog writer. My goal has never been to write a lot, but to rather explor...
-
I think that it is worth trying to understand some of the reasons we are heading towards a food crisis . The result of all of this deregulat...
© The Art of Engineering 2013 . Powered by Bootstrap , Blogger templates and RWD Testing Tool
I think there is art in everything well done. Often that "art" lies in making something complicated or difficult look simple and easy.
ReplyDeleteYou asked for examples. The best I can think of is the drive mechanism on a steam locomotive. Awesomely effective and when in motion, there is this hypnotic beauty.
Great entry! I see art in everything around me - even the beauty and simplicity of just being able to press this button et voila - technology is a beautiful art.
ReplyDeleteJean-Jacques Rousseau said: "The world of reality has its limit; the world of imagination is boundless."
Annie and Dave, thanks for your comments!
ReplyDeleteAnnie - really nice blog! I like the look, feel and colours. Good luck with all the building - I'm not too sure if I would be willing to take it on.
"The walls between art and engineering exist only in our minds." Art is without bounds it complements engineering and blends them together seamlessly. In its true essence perhaps art is everything bound only by categorization like engineering.
ReplyDeleteEngineering has no limit for others, while some say it is just end with a person's capacity.
ReplyDeleteI believe that each person has his own art. As the saying goes beauty is in the eye of the beholder and so does art. Art is defined by those who see it and appreciate it. In my opinion our everyday living is an art.
ReplyDelete